| Member | Sport | Inducted |
|---|---|---|
| Bistowski, John "Biz" | Lacrosse | 2020 |
| Ables, Tom | Football | 2011 |
| Ackerman, Dennis | Basketball | 2013 |
| Ahrenstein, Debby | Softball | 2006 |
| Alberstein, David | Water Polo | 2009 |
| Alfano, Frank | Football/ Baseball | 2015 |
| Allen, Mike | Baseball/Football | 2017 |
| Bahne, Bob | Football | 2013 |
| Basalo, Mike | Baseball | 2009 |
| Bates, Dennis | Volleyball | 2020 |
| Bennett, Ron | Tennis | 2014 |
| Bernstein, Mark | Youth Sports | 2012 |
| Bjornson, Lee | Ice Hockey/Field Hockey | 2019 |
| Bonner, Tim | Volleyball | 2017 |
| Brockett, Dick | Football | 2014 |
| Bruce, Paul | Swimming | 2009 |
| Bryson, Rob | Basketball | 2018 |
| Cain, Ed | Basketball | 2007 |
| Carbone, Fred | Basketball | 2009 |
| Carey, Don | Football | 2010 |
| Carey, Mike | Football | 2008 |
| Castagnola, Andy | Football | 2012 |
| Clarkson, Don | Football | 2007 |
| Coover, Steve | Football | 2008 |
| Cote, Larry | Volleyball | 2013 |
| Cremidan, Alex | Baseball | 2019 |
| Dabbaghian, Danielle | Water Polo | 2020 |
| Dandridge, Albert | Track & Field | 2017 |
| DeFelice, Garth | Football | 2011 |
| Desaulniers, Tom | Youth Baseball | 2009 |
| Dexter, Mark | Wrestling/Water Polo | 2019 |
| Dierdorff, Dan | Wrestling | 2011 |
| Draz, Dick | Swimming/Water Polo | 2016 |
| Drumm, Christina | Softball | 2011 |
| Duggan, Bob | Lacrosse/Football | 2006 |
| Eisele, Robert | Swimming/Diving | 2019 |
| Evans, Cal | Basketball/Football | 2008 |
| Ferguson, John | Football | 2020 |
| Fillmore, Tim | Baseball | 2014 |
| Filson, Ron | Basketball | 2011 |
| Flaherty, Ken | Football | 2007 |
| Furrer, Lou | Football | 2014 |
| Gambino, Sal | Baseball | 2020 |
| Garman, Jim | Baseball | 2011 |
| Gibillisco, Jim | Softball | 2009 |
| Gilchrist, Jim | Basketball | 2008 |
| Gomes, Manny | Basketball | 2007 |
| Gonzalez, David | Baseball | 2006 |
| Griffith, Brad | Basketball | 2015 |
| Guitierrez, Phil | Softball | 2006 |
| Hanford, Denna | Gymnastics | 2018 |
| Hardage, David | Softball/Football/Basketball | 2019 |
| Harris, Joe | Youth Baseball | 2007 |
| Hart, Mike | Baseball | 2018 |
| Harvey, Doug | Baseball | 2006 |
| Harvey, Nolan | Basketball | 2011 |
| Holly, Ken | Track & Field | 2010 |
| Holmes, Merlyn "Chip" | Track | 2020 |
| Hood, Bob | Football | 2016 |
| Kauffman, Bob | Softball | 2008 |
| Kramm, Hans | Soccer | 2008 |
| Kramm, Rosalie | Soccer | 2019 |
| Libbey, Dave | Basketball | 2009 |
| Malta, Patracia | Volleyball | 2008 |
| McAlpine, Gregory | Ice Hockey | 2020 |
| McDonald, Mike | Baseball | 2007 |
| McIntyre, Terry | Basketball | 2010 |
| Minor, Ellie | Field Hockey | 2006 |
| Mock, Kelly | Soccer | 2017 |
| Morehouse, Bruce | Water Polo | 2013 |
| Morrow, Mike | Basketball | 2016 |
| Mothershed, Mike | Football | 2017 |
| Moulder, Kathryn | Field Hockey | 2017 |
| Oakley , John | Football | 2010 |
| Paulette, John | Softball | 2009 |
| Pendersen, John | Baseball | 2010 |
| Perkins, Connie | Basketball | 2015 |
| Podraza, Tim | Football | 2018 |
| Popejoy, Lee | Soccer | 2009 |
| Powell, Linda | Basketball | 2008 |
| Riner, Rusty | Basketball | 2015 |
| Rotsart, Steven | Water Polo | 2011 |
| Runge, Ed | Baseball | 2006 |
| Runge, Paul | Baseball | 2007 |
| Russell, Patrick | Boxing | 2012 |
| Rustich, Frank | Football/ Boxing | 2006 |
| Saltzstein, Mike | Swimming | 2009 |
| Schutte, George | Football | 2006 |
| Sibbet, Jim | Football | 2008 |
| Siscon, John | Wrestling | 2018 |
| Taylor, Jack | Baseball | 2006 |
| Tellous, Bill | Football/Basketball | 2008 |
| Thopson, Jesse | Football/Basketball | 2014 |
| Tiffany, David | Soccer/ Water Polo | 2016 |
| Torres, Nacho | Baseball | 2013 |
| Villa, Cindi Lou | Field Hockey | 2007 |
| Vitale, Patty | Gymnastics | 2009 |
| Weseloh, Mike | Football | 2016 |
| White, Shelley | Youth Baseball | 2006 |
| Wilhelm, Frank | Basketball/Softball | 2019 |
| Williams, Dal | Basketball | 2010 |
| Winters, Mike | Baseball | 2012 |
| Wood, Thomas | Basketball | 2012 |
| Zapolski, Ed | Football | 2015 |